Hello and welcome back to The Stone Soup Cook–I’m glad you’re here!
Today, I’m continuing my series on the seven fundamental sauces of California Cuisine. While there is not a definitive list of foundational or “mother” sauces of California Cuisine, I am positing that they are the following: mayonnaise, vinaigrette, pesto, salsa, basic tomato sauce, Bernaise (or Hollandaise) and chimichurri sauce. I started the series by sharing my recipe for a basic mayonnaise, followed by thoughts on aioli and its siblings, pesto aioli and roasted red bell pepper aioli, both of which play equally well with vegetables and meats as they do as spreads or dips for sandwiches and bread and even crab cakes!
Today, I’m sharing my favorite recipe for tartar sauce. Living on the west coast, we have access to gorgeous, fresh seafood that is plucked from the ocean and shipped to our markets daily. When the seafood is that fresh, you don’t have to do much to it to make it taste great. However, a lovely tartar sauce is just never a bad idea.
Mr. Stone Stoup was traveling last weekend and came home raving about a pan-seared halibut special he’d had at a restaurant in Seattle. He had few details except that it was pan-seared, juicy and delicious. The next day, my buddy Paul requested a recipe for tartar sauce, explaining that fish is only the vehicle for a really awesome tartar sauce, but complaining that store-bought sauces are terrible. I couldn’t agree more.
And yet again: challenge accepted.
Today, I’m featuring pan-seared halibut with steamed vegetables, roast potatoes and hands-down, the best tartar sauce I’ve EVER had. This tartar sauce is equally good with seared salmon and crab cakes. And while I almost never fry fish (I think because I just love it too much!) this is the best tartar sauce for a fish fry you’ll ever have.
Let’s start with the fact that store-bought tartar sauces are almost always sweet. I think a good tartar sauce should be savory, so my recipe uses dill pickle relish and no sugar. But, let’s just get this straight: ain’t the mayonnaise good, ain’t no way the tartar sauce is good. So, I started my recipe for tartar sauce by making the mayo from scratch using pecan oil, which I find to be the tastiest oil for mayo:

Next, I added dill pickle relish, chopped shallots, chopped capers and a little dried parsley:

Mixed it together and friends–this is absolutely DELICIOUS–and I kid you not–it took at most 10 minutes to whip up–including the time it took to make the mayo. Now–I get it if you don’t want to make your mayo from scratch. If you use an off-the-shelf product, please use a good-quality mayo. I like Best Foods mayo myself–it’s reliably tangy, creamy and tasty. Please don’t use any of the mayos made with olive oil. My experience with them has been universally terrible–I have found that the olive oil used is always already rancid when I open the package and I’ve had to throw them out. Olive oil is great for making mayo–just make your own with fresh, high-quality olive oil. But remember: evoo has a little bitterness, which I quite like, but for some, it is a turn-off in mayo. Bottom line here is that since mayo is the main component of tartar sauce, it needs to be a good one or your tartar sauce will suffer the consequences.
For the pan-seared halibut, I selected a good, thick center-cut (it was probably 1 1/4″ thick) from my fish guy and brined it for at least an hour. Then I prepared it just like I do my pan-seared salmon and we were treated to a moist, delicious, tender and flavorful mouthful of delicate fish. And when paired with the tangy tartar sauce, it was terrific. I served it with steamed asparagus and red bell peppers and crispy oven-roasted potatoes for a show-stopping feast:

And then I recently made this lovely pan-seared salmon:

It, too, played beautifully with the tartar sauce. This sauce is also perfect for crab cakes and virtually any other seafood you’d like to pair it with.
Please join me tomorrow as I continue to play in my California kitchen with the first of my California Cuisine “mother” sauces, mayonnaise!
Until then,
Peace, love and good food,
Keri
