Weekly Menus

Balsamic Vinegar, the Rise and Fall of an Overused Condiment, and How to Find Peace With It

Hello and welcome back to The Stone Soup Cook–so glad you’re here!

Today, I’m continuing my series on the foundational sauces of California Cuisine. In the last few weeks, I’ve shared recipes involving my first choice for a foundational sauce: mayonnaise. This week, I have started sharing thoughts and recipes on my second choice for a foundational sauce: vinaigrette. At its most basic, a vinaigrette is oil, vinegar, salt and pepper. Olive oil and nut oils are great choices for oils in a vinaigrette, and the choices for an acid are similarly plentiful–from citrus to basic and designer vinegars.

In this post, I’m tackling what I consider to be one of the most overused and misunderstood vinegars on the food enhancement continuum: balsamic vinegar.

Back in the 1990’s and 2000’s, when California Cuisine was still finding its footing, and in some ways losing its way, many chefs leaned heavily into condiments such as aiolis and balsamic vinegars, using them to top almost anything from pizza to seafood and even to desserts, drizzling frantically and heavily and calling it a masterpiece of California’s bounty. In truth, many of those “masterpieces” were just a mess. And the aiolis, the balsamic vinegars and yes, the avocado toast, became a punch-line on late-night tv shows and anyone trying to get a laugh at California’s expense, which is too bad.

California Cuisine is some of the freshest and most elegant food in the world, but unfortunately, during those years of “growing pains,” a good deal of those questionable ideas caught on, especially with home cooks trying to dress up a work-a-day recipe. And boy did balsamic vinegar get overworked–hard.

Many years ago, Mr. Stone Soup and I were staying at a bed and breakfast in Napa that allowed its guests to use their professional kitchen to prepare their own meals. The bed and breakfast was situated way up on a gorgeous hillside with lots of live oaks and wildflowers. It was about 30 minutes outside of town and once you got there, you really didn’t want to leave. We stayed there many times and dinnertime typically turned into an impromptu party, with guests all preparing food and sharing their bounty with each other over a shared table. We loved it, and I learned to bring my cooking essentials and enough food and wine to share.

At one visit, we enjoyed being a part of a particularly gregarious group and had so much fun that we all decided to meet again the next evening for a repeat performance. We divvied up the food courses–I think I had salad and dessert; I know I didn’t have the main because one of the other guests announced that she was going to make us her special steak recipe. Her husband enthusiastically endorsed the plan, asserting that she made the best steak in the world! Mr. Stone Soup and I eagerly anticipated this culinary sensation with bated breath.

The next evening, everyone gathered in the kitchen for wine and appetizers and I in particular joined the evening’s main-course chef because I wanted to learn at the knee of this master. Nicole pulled her gorgeous, well-marbled New York strip steaks out of a butcher-paper-wrapped package and placed them in a large saute pan. I assumed she was going to sear them and maybe smoke them? grill them? I wasn’t sure. I asked what seasonings she used and she said, “no need!” and then produced her “secret ingredient,” and you guessed it–it was balsamic vinegar. She proceeded to upend not one, but two bottles of balsamic vinegar over those poor, helpless steaks, fully submerging them in the thick, viscous vinegar product. I was aghast. I didn’t know all that much about balsamic at the time, but knew from eating it in salad dressings that it had a very strong flavor. Now, steak is a rich, flavorful meat, but even it can’t stand up to the abuse of being engulfed in balsamic vinegar. And worse than that, Nicole then bragged that this was the easiest recipe in the world–now all she had to do was sit back and let it simmer for about an hour while we enjoyed our wine and appetizers…which was hard to do given the assault of mephitic vinegar smells coming from that pan.

O.M.G.

Nicole was actually a delightful person, but, and I say this with all due respect–she was hands-down one of the worst cooks I have ever, ever encountered. To be fair, she was influenced by the trends of California Cuisine of the day, although I doubt any chef in his or her right mind ever took the use of balsamic vinegar to that extreme. As I recall, the steak was pretty tender (I mean, after drowning it all that vinegar, how could it not be), but after an hour of simmering, it was cooked to death and just an acrid mess of angry, overpowering sweet-sour and bitter beef. It was all I could do to choke down even a bite of that meat. I kept thinking “what did this steak ever do to you! No piece of beef deserves this abuse!” And worse than eating the steaks was the fact that another couple who joined us were wine-makers. Their contribution to the meal was a selection of their really lovely wines. None of us could taste anything after assaulting our taste buds with those tragically prepared steaks.

In the end, it was actually a really good lesson in the art of restraint.

Here’s the moral of the story: balsamic vinegar is a perfectly good condiment…when used in small quantities. A little really does go a long way. And folks–it doesn’t–I repeat–DOESN’T–belong on everything. Mixed with olive oil, it makes a lovely dressing when dripped onto cheese. And it’s delicious as part of a dipping sauce for bread or used with a light hand on pizza, or even as a component in a steak sauce. It’s also a great ingredient in a vinaigrette to dress sturdy salads like this one made with spinach, apples, (or pears) blueberries and walnuts–the high acid in the balsamic is a nice foil to the sweetness of the fruits and the strong flavor of the spinach.

But folks–a steak that’s been boiled in it for an hour is not good. In fact, it’s not just not good–it’s inedible, and a ticket to the all-night jamboree of heartburn.

When I say a little goes a long way, I mean it–I ordered these little eyedroppers from Amazon:

and they work just great as a delivery vehicle for balsamic over a caprese salad:

Now let’s chat for a minute about choosing balsamic vinegar. The truth is, the really good stuff–the stuff that’s aged for 25 years in wooden casks–is very expensive and pretty hard to get your hands on, especially in a US grocery store. But all is not lost.

There are three basic levels of balsamic vinegar. They are D.O.P. (meaning Protected Designation of Origin). This is the most sought after balsamic and comes from Modena or Reggio Emilia, Italy. It’s standards are strictly regulated and it has been aged for a minimum of 12 years. The next level is “condimento,” which is generally from Modeno or Reggio Emilia, but is held to less high standards and is aged for less than 12 years. The final grade of balsamic, and the one you’re most likely to find at your local grocery store is “I.G.P.” (Indicazione Geografica Protetta). It is a high quality product that is made in Modena and adheres to standards similar to those of the D.O.P. It is aged for at least 60 days in a cask and if labeled “aged,” it is aged for 3 years and is generally a reliably good balsamic vinegar.

This one was recently named the overall winner of a taste test of about 20 readily available IGP balsamic vinegars :

I picked it up from Amazon for about $20. While I’m not a huge fan of balsamic, I appreciated that it wasn’t as overtly sweet as many of the balsamics can be and it has an overall balanced flavor. And at the price, along with the fact that this bottle will last me a long time (mainly because I won’t be upending it over a steak!), I think it’s a pretty good value.

I hope you’ll join me later in the week for more fun with vinaigrettes.

Until then,

Peace, love and good food,

Keri