Hello and welcome back to The Stone Soup Cook–I’m so glad you’re here!
This week, I’m continuing my Lenten meditative dive into Biblical foods. Last week, I dove into different kinds of bread. Being the symbol of the Body of Christ in the Bible, bread felt like the right place to start my look at Biblical foods, and I featured pizza dough (or flat bread), basic yeast bread, focaccia bread and croutons. It was a fun week, although I’m still doing some more research on the perfect recipe for focaccia bread. I promise to keep you posted on my progress.
This week, I’m taking a dive into olive oil and olives. Olives and olive oil are prominently featured throughout the Bible as symbols of peace, prosperity, hope and new beginnings. In the book of Genesis, a dove returns to Noah’s Ark with an olive leaf (or branch) in its beak heralding the news that the flood waters had receded and that life could begin anew. I just love that image and indeed, a dove with an olive branch permeates throughout history and popular culture as a symbol or message of peace.

Throughout the Bible, olive oil held an important role, being used for anointments in ceremonies and for fueling lamps for light.
Olive oil is still commonly used in religious ceremonies, it is also widely used for cooking, not only for its unique flavor, but also for its numerous health benefits.
Olive oil is a fat, which is one of those triggering words for a lot of folks. But–there are fats and then there are fats. Trans fats, for example, are industrially-treated fats and they’re generally held to be bad for our health. However, fats are not necessarily bad for us. While nutritional studies are notoriously funded by whatever industry is profiting from the food or ingredient, olive oil has generally been held to be good (actually, VERY good) for our bodies by not just the olive industry, but also by health professionals.
While doing research for this article, I found a dizzying array of facts (and probably fiction) about olive oil. However, most sources seem to agree on a few things:
Olive oil contains polyphenols, which are compounds that are beneficial to our health. They are anti-inflammatories and antioxidents, both of which lower the risk of heart disease, protect against cancer and fight inflammation.
But not all olive oils are the same!
Olive oil can have a pretty strong flavor, and not all like it. The olive oil industry to the rescue! Heating and chemically treating olive oil moderates the flavor. And therein lie the different types of olive oils.
Extra virgin olive oil, or EVOO, is the least processed of the olive oils and retains the highest levels of polyphenols, and hence is the most nutritious of the different types of olive oils. It is also the most flavorful, which can be off-putting to some if you’re not used to the flavor. EVOO can have a relatively strong, herbaceous and a slightly bitter flavor to it. I love it, but it’s not everyone’s cup of tea.
Virgin olive oil is processed more than EVOO, and therefore has a milder flavor. The “processing” is achieved by adding heat and chemical treatments. Polyphenols are sensitive to the processing, and hence, virgin olive oil is less nutritious than EVOO; but virgin olive oil still retains a fair amount of the same health benefits as the EVOO.
“Light” or “refined” olive oil is the most processed of the three and therefore has the mildest flavor of all the olive oils, but also has the least nutritional value of the three.
And now some things that I’m not so sure about:
There’re lots of sources out there that will tell you that olive oil is the best thing to use for all your cooking needs. This claim has to come with some asterisks. EVOO is great for salad dressings, dips, drizzles and any manner of things you don’t have to cook. But EVOO has quite a low smoke point, which makes it not ideal for anything but lower-heat cooking.
For example–I would use EVOO to saute vegetables or even for some baking. But I wouldn’t use it to sear a steak, where you need to keep the pan at a high heat for several minutes. While most of the sources I found agree that smoking oil will not be particularly harmful to you (other than inhaling the smoke, which is…not all that pleasant), it just won’t taste good. Other oils, such as pecan oil, avocado oil, safflower and peanut oils are much better choices for high-heat cooking.
EVOO has a smoke point of somewhere around 375-410*. But consider this: at around 260*, EVOO will lose around 35% of its polyphenol potency. At around 340*, it loses around 75% of the polyphenol potency. And at temperatures somewhere a little over 400*, it will start to smoke. So…it seems to me that using EVOO for lower temperature cooking is the best choice for both practicality’s sake and for health benefits.
And now for the asterisks: virgin olive oil and “light” or “refined” olive oil both have higher smoke points than EVOO, although the information I found varied from source to source as to a precise smoke point, so I couldn’t say exactly how much higher those smoke points would be. But keep in mind that the more processed the oil is, the fewer polyphenols present.
So with that introduction to the world of olive oil, let’s start our recipe dive with some simple, but delicious ways to showcase olives and olive oil while also enjoying all the wonderful health benefits that come with them.
First up, my basic vinaigrette:

Next, this lovely little dipping oil:

Join me again tomorrow when I share more information and recipes featuring olives and olive oil–
Until then,
Peace, love and good food,
Keri
