Hello and welcome back to The Stone Soup Cook! I’m so glad you’re here!
Is there anything better than a baked potato? I count baked potatoes as one of my “desert island” things–you know–if you could only have one (fill in the blank) on a desert island, what would it be? I’d be tempted to say baked potatoes as my only food. I’d probably come to my senses, but…I don’t know.
I was talking to my mom the other evening when she was making loaded baked potatoes for dinner. She waxed poetic about the virtues of the loaded baked potato as a “one-and-done” meal. She was adding broccoli, onions, sausage, cheese and butter to her potato. And it got me thinking about back in the 1980’s when loaded baked potatoes were all the rage. I think it was Wendy’s that featured a baked potato bar with all kinds of toppings where you could build your own baked potato. Wendy’s still has loaded potatoes on their menu, but really–back in the mid ’80’s you couldn’t walk down the street without tripping over a restaurant that featured loaded baked potatoes.
Maybe 2025 is the year for a loaded baked potato comeback….hmmmm…
This week, I’m highlighting recipes that use leftovers and “found food.” Yesterday, I featured chili that I made using leftover pinto beans I had made the night before. It occurred to me that a baked potato topped with that chili, plus some vegetables, cheese, onions, etc., would be a pretty darned good “one-and-done” meal, as my mom pointed out! Obviously, the potato is the starch. The chili, with all the nice beans and beef, is full of protein. After rummaging around in the fridge, I came up with some broccoli and a piece of leftover onion, I added some cheese and sour cream, and viola! Dinner was served: I give you, the loaded baked potato:

Folks–this was a REALLY easy meal. AND–it was really good! Baking the potato was the longest lead-time item.
So what’s the best way to bake a potato? And what’s the best potato for baking? There are a lot of passionate bloggers out there that have opinions on this.
Most folks seem to prefer russet for baking. Most also advise that you bake them at high heat (~425*) with no foil. Scrub the potatoes to remove any dirt and then rub the skins with a high-heat oil (I like pecan oil, but avocado oil would work fine), sprinkle with salt and pepper and put them right onto the oven rack. This seems messy to me. I would at least put the potato(es) onto a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper for easy clean-up. For an average 6-8-oz potato, the times vary, but at 425, it should take about an hour, turning the potato halfway through the cook time for even cooking. This will result in a nicely browned, crispy-skinned potato.
Still others swear by the foil-bake method: rub the scrubbed potatoes with oil, sprinkle with salt and pepper and bake at 425 for an hour or so, or until the flesh is very soft.
I prefer a combination of those bake methods: I bake at 425* for a total of about an hour and 15 minutes (so–longer than most recommend, but I just like a softer, creamier interior to my potato) and I start with foil and then remove the potatoes from the foil for about 20-30 minutes to crisp the skins. I think the skins get too crispy if you leave them uncovered for too long–much like a turkey. I remove the foil from the top of the turkey for the last half-hour of baking to get a nice crispy-brown, but not overly-browned skin.
I also like to use Yukon gold potatoes for baking, which…no one else seems to do. I stumbled on baking Yukon golds years and years ago when I wanted a baked potato with a steak and had no other kinds of potatoes in the house, and I’ve never gone back. Yukon golds are waxier and their skins are a little more delicate, leading to nice browning with a more subtle crunch to the crust. They also have a nuttier flavor that I just like better than russets. Yukons will not give you that “fluffy” texture that a russet will when baked, but I like the creamier texture, so… There are no wrong answers here.
So there it is–the simplest, most satisfying dinner around. I hope you enjoy it!
Tune in tomorrow when I’ll be featuring my “Hail Mary Chicken Casserole.”
Until then,
Peace, love and good food,
Keri
