Weekly Menus

An Abundance of Cast Iron Continues: Smithey 6″ Skillet

Hello and welcome back to The Stone Soup Cook!

This week and next, I am featuring cast iron cookware. I am a huge fan of cast iron and cook with it almost every day. This week, I am featuring a comparison of small skillets from Lodge, Finex and Smithey.

Today, I’m going to focus on the Smithey skillet. **I have not been compensated for this review and all the opinions are my own.**

I became acquainted with Smithey when I was shopping in a favorite little kitchen store in my hometown in Texas about a year ago. The line was new to me and caught my eye because it is absolutely gorgeous. I acquired the adorably tiny 6″ skillet shortly thereafter because I just had to try some of this beautiful cookware.

Let’s start by getting to know this skillet a little better–out of the box, this is what it looks like:

And here is what my skillet looks like today:

Smithey has a couple of different product lines in their inventory–classic cast iron and forged steel. They were founded in 2015 and are made in Charleston, South Carolina. Smithey products are pricey. This 6″ skillet is priced at $85 before tax and shipping (if applicable).

This is a substantial skillet. The official weight of this skillet given on the Smithey website is +/- 2.5 pounds. I actually have two of the 6″ skillets and both of them weigh in at about 2 pounds 11 ounces. Given that one of the features widely touted by devotees of cast iron is its ability to retain heat, the weight of the Smithey, while notable, does not discourage me.

Smithey is pre-seasoned and has an overall length of a little over 11″. The handle on the Smithey is about 4.5 inches, a quarter of an inch longer than the Blacklock, and I like this. The Smithey also includes a “helper” handle on the opposite side of the handle, and I like that, too–it is a nice feature for handling a hot pan especially when cleaning.

Right out of the box, the Smithey is simply beautiful. The skillets are polished to a lovely, shiny bronze color. All of the skillets have pour spouts on both sides, which is nice, and heat rings on the bottoms, allowing the skillet to sit slightly away from a flame. The pour spouts are a little deeper than the Blacklock.

The handle is fine, especially for the size of the skillet, but it does get hot quickly–after about 3 minutes on medium-high heat, I found myself reaching for a pot holder.

Smithey also features a satin, milled finish on the bottom of the skillets. This is a feature that was important to me when investigating my first purchase of cast iron. I never liked the pebble finish on Lodge because I felt that it would never come completely clean and never become totally non-stick, like cast iron is supposed to. After my experience with the Lodge Blacklock skillet, I’m not entirely convinced of this. However, the satin finish certainly doesn’t inhibit these goals.

So let’s get cooking.

The first thing I did was to go ahead and steam clean the skillet and then season it. I always use the method recommended by Kent Rollins, the undisputed king of cast iron cooking. He recommends scraping the skillet clean with a wooden spatula and then heating the pan to smoking hot before rinsing under very hot water. [Be sure to use oven mitts on both hands for this process, as the skillet is very hot and the steam from the cleaning can cause burns!] I then poured a small amount of pecan oil into the skillet and rubbed it in well. I let the skillet cool before cooking with it.

I decided to cook bacon and eggs in my skillet. Please note that Smithey advises that bacon is not the best thing to cook in your skillet right out of the box. My skillet is almost a year old, so I had no fear 🙂

I used medium-high heat and the bacon did just fine. I turned the bacon after about every 90 seconds and found that I didn’t have to worry about it cooking too quickly as long as I was reasonably vigilant. It took about 7 minutes before it was nicely crisp and done.

The Smithey cooked the bacon up nicely and I had no issues with sticking. I cleaned most of the bacon grease out of the pan and cracked an egg into the skillet:

Oops. That’s entirely my fault! As you can see below, the egg cooked evenly and I had no trouble flipping it, although there was a little sticking.

Clean-up, however, was very easy. Any egg residue came off with a couple of scrapes of a wooden spatula and steam-cleaning took care of the rest very quickly.

Overall, I thought that the Smithey cooked beautifully and I am looking forward to seeing how it performs for baking tasks, such as biscuits and for more delicate tasks, such as searing fish.

As I mentioned, I found that the handle got hot pretty quickly–though not as quickly as the Blacklock. I found myself reaching for a pot holder after only about 2 minutes of cooking on medium-high heat with the Blacklock, but I was reaching for my pot holder after only about 3 with the Smithey.

As always, when I finished my cooking task, I promptly cleaned and seasoned the skillet.

Tomorrow, I will feature the gorgeous 8″ Finex skillet.

See you tomorrow and in the meantime–

Peace, love and good food!

Keri