Weekly Menus

An Abundance of Cast Iron

Today, I’m going to start a two week conversation about cast iron.

If you’ve followed me for any time, you already know that I LOVE cooking with cast iron. It heats evenly, handles tricky work like searing a delicate fish, baking, the flames of a grill, or a campfire and a casserole with equal ease. I have a variety of skillets and stock pots and use them almost every day, and as The Stone Soup Cook, its longevity is greatly appealing to me–buy it once and keep it forever.

People have been using cast iron for cooking for hundreds of years, and many a cast iron skillet has been handed down through the generations. I know that many of you are probably curious about cast iron but may be intimidated by its weight and, let’s face it, its upkeep. There are lots of choices out there and over the next couple of weeks, I’m going to try to introduce you to several brands and types of cast iron–from expensive to affordable and from light to heavy.

So why am I tackling this conversation right now, when cast iron has been around for such a long time? The other day, I was on a zoom call with family, and one of my brothers-in-law mentioned that Yeti (yes, that venerable manufacturer of insulated beverage containers and coolers) had recently come out with a 12″ cast iron skillet that cost–wait for it–$400.00! Yikes. I did a quick internet search and not only did they come out with one, they sold out of their first production run almost immediately. As of this writing, they are again available, but may not be for long.

Cast iron can get expensive, don’t get me wrong. But $400.00 for a skillet is the most expensive I’ve ever heard of. And don’t get your hopes up–I’m not going to race out there and get one to see if it’s worth the money. And neither did Yeti offer to send me one to test, either 😉

However, I do already have several different kinds of cast iron of varying weight, cost and features, in my collection; and I bought a new, relatively inexpensive skillet to test alongside the cast iron I already have to compare and contrast.

Over the next couple of weeks I’m going to give the pros and cons of each, I’ll discuss care, upkeep and use of the different types of cast iron out there. We’ll go over features, benefits of the various types and brands and discuss the things I like about each one and the things I’m not crazy about. Finally, I’ll cook with each of them and not only provide recipes, but discuss how each different brand/type handles the same task.

I’m going to begin our discussion about traditional cast iron with a comparison of skillets. **I bought all of these skillets myself and have received no compensation from any of these companies. All the opinions are my own.**

Let’s meet the contestants:

First up is Smithey:

Next up, is Finex:

Finally, Blacklock by Lodge:

On Wednesday, I’ll be going over the features and benefits of each of these skillets and I’ll provide a simple cooking demonstration to see how each skillet handles the task. Over the next two weeks, I’ll put these skillets through their tasks and show how each handles baking, searing, sautéing and more.

See you on Wednesday and in the meantime,

Peace, love and good food!

Keri