Sourdough Bread

Prep Time 5 hrs
Cook Time 45 mins
Rest Time 16 hrs
Total Time 21 hrs 45 mins
Difficulty: Intermediate
Best Season: Suitable throughout the year
Description

OK, so let's all just calm down about sourdough bread.

It’s not that exotic and it’s actually pretty easy to make--it just takes a long time.  Before I “got it,” I read articles by and encountered a whole bunch of sanctimonious folks who acted like they were in a secret society of “sourdough wizards.”  Sheesh.  I’m not too proud to say that I was very intimidated by it, and when I finally got over that, I made a whole bunch of mistakes.  

I’m happy to say that I have come up with a pretty fool-proof way of achieving what I think is bakery-quality sourdough bread in my own home—no secret handshake required!

The first hurdle is the starter itself.  I tried making my own--it got moldy.  I got some starter from a friend and I never could get it to take.  I fed it and fed it, and it just never really took off.  That same friend advised me to just go to a bakery and buy some starter.  I did that, fed it diligently for a few days, and eureka--a really good, strong starter emerged and I still have it today.  So...you do you, but buying it from a bakery was easy and cheap--my starter was two bucks.

The next hurdle was that I found sourdough recipes to be extremely rigid in their timing.  You had to make the dough one day and bake it the next morning.  I have been baking yeast breads for decades, and I found this timing limiting if I wanted to make soup and bread for dinner and still have the bread a little warm when I sat down to eat.  Yeast breads generally do not have the rigid timing limitations.

Secondly, I found that the loaves I did manage to make were just leaden—not the light, airy sourdough I was used to getting from a bakery.  

Fundamentally, I didn’t understand the process and what was happening to make a loaf of sourdough.  Every recipe I found had a different theory of creating a light, airy loaf.  Here’s the big secret: in addition to having a good, strong sourdough starter and using the proper type of flour, you have to manually incorporate air into the dough. 

I found lots of advice in the metaverse.  Some folks advised using additives, other encouraged you to say magic incantations over the dough.  Whatever.  The method I settled on is folding the dough over and over on itself.  The first time I tried the folding method, I saw tiny bubbles in the layers formed by the folding.  The way I do it is to kind of roll the dough out on a well floured surface and fold it over several times on itself every 30 minutes for about 3 hours.  Once I used this method, I saw all the tiny bubbles on the surface of the loaf and it started to rise slightly between folds.

Furthermore, I learned that sourdough is not at all as finicky as I had been led to believe.  I learned that you can put the fold-treated dough into the fridge to be baked on your schedule.  I have left the loaf in the fridge for as long as 20 hours before baking it—no problem.  That having been said, I do always bake it the next day.

But, perhaps the most important thing I learned about making a light loaf, was a happy accident.  I was using a recipe that, with a few tweaks, I liked pretty well.  One day, I mis-measured the flour and added probably 100 fewer grams than I was supposed to.  The result was a very wet dough, to which I had to add quite a lot of flour to in the folding process to keep it from sticking.  Ultimately, the dough was looser and easier to handle.  I actually didn’t think about it too much, but did wonder if I had done something wrong.  I baked it, and to my delight, it was light, airy and had a spingy texture—perfect for toasting and making sandwiches.  

The next time I made it, I realized my mistake and measured out the proper amount of flour.  I wasn’t as happy with the result and for the next loaf, I decreased the amount of flour and then continued to play with the proportions until I finally feel that I have a really good loaf—not too springy, not too heavy—just right!

Next, every recipe I found wanted you to cook the loaf at 450-500*.  My loaves kept coming out burned.  I slowly lowered the temperature of the oven until I finally settled on about 425* and it seems to be the magic number for my oven.  Please note that everyone's oven is different and you may have to experiment a little.

Finally, there was the “tipping” process.  And I’m not talking about cows here.  All the recipes I found casually said “carefully tip the dough from the bowl into the Dutch oven.”  The words that they leave out here are “the branding iron hot Dutch oven.”  How in the “bleep” can you do that safely??!!  I burned myself the first time and the second time used more olive oil in my bowl, until finally I remembered Isaac Asimov’s “Fahrenheit 451.” Since I bake my bread at about 425*, I decided to try using parchment paper to transfer the dough to the Dutch oven, and viola--success!  I have perfected my method over the last few months, and I’ll share it with you in the recipe below.  By using this method, I find that I am able to preserve the rise that I get from the dough after I leave it in the fridge, resulting in a lovely light and well textured loaf.  And, bonus! Since I cook the loaf with the parchment paper in the Dutch oven, the paper creates “handles” for taking the bread out of the Dutch oven, too.  The bread never sticks to it and although I don’t get any design on the bottom of the loaf, it’s a pretty safe and foolproof method.

Ingredients
  • 120 g Sourdough Starter
  • 350 g Lukewarm Water
  • 500 g Bread Flour (12-14% protein content)
  • 2 heaping tsp Kosher salt
  • ~25* g Very hot water (*I've used as much as 30 grams of water in this step)
Instructions
  1. 1

    The first time I made sourdough, I used every bowl and pot in my kitchen.  I have since streamlined the process.  

    Start with a large mixing bowl.  Set it on your kitchen scale and zero out the weight of the bowl.  Measure out about 120 grams of starter (I have used as little as 100 and as much as 125).  

  2. 2

    Add the 350 grams (it's about 1.5 cups) of lukewarm water to the bowl.

  3. 3

    Using a whisk (I like the one pictured above because I can easily mix this dough, but also the dough is easy to pull out when it sticks in the mixing process), stir vigorously to dissolve the starter into the water.

  4. 4

    Zero out the scale again.  Now add the 500 grams of flour and mix the dough.  You don't need to knead the dough--just mix it in with the open whisk and try to get most of the flour incorporated into the starter and water mixture.  

  5. 5

    You're going to end up with a pretty sticky, shaggy, messy ball of dough, such as pictured above--don't worry about that.  Cover it with something to keep it from drying out and leave it be for about 30 minutes to rest.

  6. 6

    Next, fill a small, lidded jar, such as the one pictured, with very hot water to warm it up.  I use the water from my instant hot water dispenser.  Once you get the jar nice and hot, add the two heaping teaspoons of Kosher salt.  To that, add about 25 grams of very hot water--but I've added as much as 30 grams with no problem.  Shake vigorously for 30-60 seconds to dissolve the salt as much as possible and then put it aside.

  7. 7

    After 30 minutes of letting the dough rest, again shake the jar containing the salt and water vigorously (the water should have cooled to just lukewarm at this point), open the jar and immediately pour the saltwater mixture over the dough.  Now, using your hands, just sort of mash the saltwater mixture into the dough.  This is going to make quite a loose, wet dough.  That's fine.  Leave it to rest for about an hour.

  8. 8

    After about an hour, Prepare another bowl (mine is a little smaller than the large mixing bowl I for mixing up the dough) by wiping some very good quality olive oil on the interior to keep the dough from sticking to it. And please, please use good olive oil here!  There are so few ingredients in the bread, please don't ruin it with rancid olive oil!  

    Now uncover the dough and pull it out onto a well-floured cutting board.  You will need a fair amount of flour on the board, as the dough will have relaxed and loosened up at this point.  Dump the dough out onto the board, and flatten it out into a long rectangle.  Flop it over a couple of times, letting it get floured up on either side until you're able to handle it without getting too sticky and then fold each of the long ends over to the center.  Now turn it over and sort of roll it out until you have a rectangle again (it doesn't have to be as long as the first rectangle--you just want it to be long enough to fold the ends over again).  

  9. 9

    Fold the ends over again and repeat the process 2-3 more times.  

    I have read recipes that say you can stretch the dough--I don't.  I just roll it around a little to flatten it out and then fold it over on itself and it just works--and it's EASY because my method creates a loose, wet dough.  Continue this process until you have rolled and folded the dough every 30 minutes 6-7 times, each time returning the dough to the oiled bowl.  Renew the oil if necessary, as the dough will soak up a little of it throughout this process.  

  10. 10

    Before returning the dough to the bowl for the last time, place the dough on a sheet of parchment paper large enough to wrap around the dough and lop over the edges of the bowl.  Cover the bowl with saran wrap or a reusable elastic cover and place in the fridge.  Leave it at least overnight and longer if necessary, until you're ready to bake.  However, was I stated before, I have always baked the dough within about 18 hours and never left it longer than 24 hours.

     

  11. 11

    When you're ready to bake, place a cast iron Dutch oven in the oven and begin heating to 425*.  Let the oven and empty Dutch oven heat for about an hour.  Once heated thoroughly, carefully (with thick oven mitts!) remove the Dutch oven from the oven. Take the branding iron hot cover off the Dutch oven, and carefully lift the sourdough dough out of the bowl using the "handles" formed by the parchment paper.  Lower the parchment paper containing the dough into the branding-iron hot Dutch oven (taking care not to burn yourself!).  Make sure you have your oven mitts on and replace the hot lid.  Put the hot Dutch oven back into the oven and cook with the lid on for 25 minutes.  After 25 minutes, open the oven and remove the lid.  At this point, I always turn the Dutch oven 180* to make sure the loaf cooks evenly.  Set the timer for another 20 minutes.

    At the 20 minute mark, the loaf should be golden brown and gorgeous!  Take the Dutch oven out of the oven and carefully remove the baked loaf from the Dutch oven.  I have had good success using the "handles" created by the parchment paper, but be careful because they become rather brittle and fragile during the baking process.

    Turn the loaf out onto a wire rack and let cool.  It will be a dark, golden brown and NO MATTER HOW TEMPTING, DO NOT CUT INTO THE LOAF AS SOON AS IT COMES OUT OF THE OVEN.  It is still cooking! Let it sit on the wire rack for about another hour to let the inside of the loaf continue to cook.  If you cut into it too soon, you'll find pudding inside.  No fair asking me how I know.  

    After about an hour, slice into it when it's still a little warm and slather with some yummy, salty Kerrygold butter!  YUM.

Keywords: Foolproof Sourdough Recipe
Read it online: https://thestonesoupcook.com/recipe/sourdough-bread/

Thank you for visiting my site!  I hope you love the recipe!